How We Choose Books for Five-Star Reads

Our approach to clean romance, faith, and finding stories worth recommending.
If you’ve spent any time around The Clean Romance Podcast, you’ve probably noticed something about us.
We love books.
Like, really love books.
We love the swoony heroes, the hilarious banter, the emotional plot twists, and those stories that leave us thinking about fictional characters long after we’ve turned the final page.
But we’re also pretty particular about which books we recommend.
And because the term “clean romance” can mean different things to different readers, we want you to know exactly what we mean when we say a book belongs in our Five-Star Reads collection.
Not because we think everyone has to read exactly the way we do.
But because we believe you deserve to know what you’re getting when you trust us with your next read.
First, a Little About Our Hearts
We’re both Christians. We’re also romance authors, avid readers, wives, moms, and two friends who can turn just about any conversation into a discussion about books.
Our faith isn’t something we separate from our reading lives. It influences what we write, what we read, and what we choose to recommend.
But we want to be clear about something from the beginning.
Reading clean romance doesn’t make us righteous. Jesus does that.
That’s an important distinction.
We’ve both seen how conversations about purity, entertainment, and personal convictions can become tangled up with shame, legalism, and the idea that following Jesus means checking enough boxes to earn His approval.
And that’s not the gospel.
We don’t pursue clean entertainment because we think we can make ourselves worthy of God’s love by following a list of rules.
We pursue it because we already know how deeply we’re loved.
As Tiffany shared in one of our podcast conversations, Christ’s love compels us. Our desire to honor God should flow from our relationship with Him, not from a desperate attempt to earn His favor.
And we want our approach to books to reflect both grace and truth.
We’re not perfect readers, and we don’t pretend to be. We’re still learning, growing, and sometimes discovering that our own assumptions need a little work.
But we do want to be intentional.

What Qualifies a Book for Five-Star Reads?
Our Five-Star Reads collection isn’t an open directory where any author can upload a book and call it clean.
It’s a curated collection of books that at least one of us has personally recommended.
We look for compelling stories, memorable characters, and romantic relationships that make us want to keep turning the pages.
And we consider the content and values of those stories, too.
Here are the principles that guide us.
Our standard
What Makes Our Five-Star Reads?
-
No explicit sexual content
Romance without graphic scenes.
-
Little to no profanity
Language and humor matter.
-
Relationships that honor love
Stories that value commitment and faithfulness.
-
A story worth recommending
Compelling characters, real chemistry, and heart.
Clean is the starting point. A great story is the goal.
1. No Explicit Sexual Content
This is probably the most familiar expectation associated with clean romance.
We don’t recommend books with graphic sexual scenes.
That doesn’t mean our romances are devoid of chemistry or affection. We love a swoony kiss as much as anyone.
But we believe romantic tension can be built through emotional intimacy, meaningful gestures, restraint, and the development of a relationship rather than explicit physical descriptions.
Our approach is informed by passages such as 1 Thessalonians 4:3–5 and Matthew 5:27–28, which call believers to sexual purity in both actions and thoughts.
We recognize that different readers may draw boundaries in different places. But for our recommendations, avoiding explicit sexual content is a foundational standard.
2. Relationships That Honor Love and Commitment
We gravitate toward stories that portray love, marriage, faithfulness, and commitment as things worth honoring.
That means we aren’t looking for books that celebrate adultery, infidelity, or sexual relationships outside marriage as ideals.
Hebrews 13:4 speaks about honoring marriage, and that’s a value we want reflected in the stories we recommend.
Now, does that mean every character has to have a spotless romantic history?
Of course not.
Some of the most meaningful stories feature characters who have made serious mistakes, experienced betrayal, or are trying to rebuild their lives.
We don’t believe portraying a sinful choice is the same as endorsing it.
A book can explore infidelity, sexual sin, or broken relationships without glorifying those things.
What matters to us is the overall message of the story and how those choices are treated.
We love redemption arcs. We love stories about forgiveness and restoration. We love seeing imperfect people grow.
We just don’t want the story to ask us to celebrate something Scripture teaches us to avoid.
What clean does not mean
A Story Can Be Clean and Still…
Include Real Life
Grief, betrayal, past mistakes, broken relationships, difficult choices, and redemption.
It’s About the Portrayal
We consider how those experiences are handled, what the story celebrates, and the overall message.
3. Little to No Profanity or Crude Language
We also look for books that avoid strong profanity, vulgar speech, and excessive crude humor.
Passages like Ephesians 4:29, Ephesians 5:4, and Colossians 3:8 remind us that words matter.
And we believe that principle applies not only to the things we say but also to the language we regularly consume.
Now, a little transparency here: we’re human.
It’s possible that a book we’ve recommended in the past contained a mild word or two that we didn’t remember when discussing it.
We do our best to pay attention to these things, and we want to be honest rather than pretend we have a perfect memory for every sentence in every book we’ve read.
Our goal is to recommend books that are generally free from profanity and crude language, and to flag relevant content when we’re aware of it.
4. A View of Romance Informed by Our Christian Faith
This is one of the areas where our standards may be more specific than the general publishing industry’s definition of clean romance.
We approach romantic relationships through a traditional Christian understanding of marriage as a covenant between one man and one woman, rooted in Genesis 2:24 and reiterated by Jesus in Matthew 19.
Because of that conviction, our curated romance recommendations focus on male-female romantic relationships rather than stories centered on same-sex romance.
We recognize that not every reader or author shares our theological perspective.
And we want to be equally clear that disagreement is not an excuse for cruelty, mockery, or treating anyone as less worthy of dignity and kindness.
Every person is made in God’s image. That truth should shape the way we speak about people, especially when we disagree.
Our goal isn’t to police what everyone else reads or writes. It’s to be transparent about the convictions that guide the books we choose to feature.
5. Stories That Offer More Than a Checklist
This one is important.
We don’t want Five-Star Reads to become nothing more than a list of books that successfully avoided certain words or scenes.
A book can be technically clean and still be a disappointing read.
We want stories with heart.
Stories that make us laugh out loud, stay up past our bedtime, fall in love with fictional characters, or think about something in a new way.
We want emotional depth, satisfying character development, and romances that make us believe in the power of love and commitment.
Sometimes that looks like a lighthearted rom-com full of ridiculous misunderstandings.
Sometimes it’s a deeply emotional story about grief, forgiveness, or second chances.
We don’t expect every book to preach a sermon.
And we don’t expect every book to be explicitly Christian.
But we do want the stories we recommend to be worth your time.
Two of us
Two Readers. Different Tastes. Shared Standards.
Sarah
Tiffany
At least one of us has to genuinely recommend a book before it earns a place. We don’t have to agree on everything — we do have to agree on the standard.
Does Every Five-Star Read Have Christian Content?
No!
We love Christian romance, but we also read and recommend clean general-market romance.
Some books feature characters whose faith is central to the story. Others include subtle faith elements. And some have no religious content at all.
We believe there can be value in stories that reflect qualities like faithfulness, kindness, sacrifice, forgiveness, and commitment even when those stories aren’t explicitly about Christianity.
Our Book Finder is designed to help you distinguish between different levels of faith content so you can find books that suit your preferences.
Does Five-Star Reads Mean Every Book Is Perfect?
We wish!
But no.
Five-Star Reads represents books we’ve chosen to recommend, not a promise that every reader will give every title five stars.
Reading is subjective. We don’t all connect with the same characters, writing styles, or tropes.
Sometimes Sarah loves a book that Tiffany hasn’t read. Sometimes Tiffany falls head over heels for a story that Sarah might not have chosen for herself.
And that’s okay!
We’re two different readers with different tastes, and we think that’s part of what makes our recommendations fun.
We also recognize that content preferences can vary, even among readers who share our faith.
That’s why we encourage you to check available content notes and use your own judgment, especially if you have particular sensitivities or concerns.
Our recommendations are personal and intentional, but they aren’t guarantees that every book will be the perfect fit for every reader.
What About Sponsored Books?
We love partnering with authors to introduce readers to new books.
But sponsorship and editorial recommendation are two different things.
An author sponsoring a podcast episode doesn’t automatically earn a place in our Five-Star Reads collection.
Our editorial recommendations are based on our own reading experiences and standards, not on whether someone has paid to advertise.
When content is sponsored, we want you to know.
And when we recommend a book because we genuinely love it, we want you to be able to trust that recommendation.
How a book gets here
Recommended ≠ Sponsored
Five-Star Reads
Chosen because at least one host genuinely recommends the book.
Sponsored Features
Paid promotional placements, always labeled as sponsorships.
Every sponsor is vetted against the same standard — and we turn plenty down.
Paying for a sponsorship does not earn a book a place in Five-Star Reads. A Five-Star Read is one of us saying we have read it and we stand behind it.
The Verse That Brings Us Back to Why We Do This
One of our favorite passages for thinking about the stories we consume is Philippians 4:8:
Whatever is true, noble, right, pure, lovely, admirable, excellent, or praiseworthy—think about such things.
We don’t believe that means every story has to be sunshine and rainbows.
The Bible itself is full of broken people, difficult circumstances, and stories of profound suffering.
But we do believe it calls us to be thoughtful about what we dwell on and what we allow to shape our hearts.
That’s the spirit behind Five-Star Reads.
We’re not trying to create an impossible set of rules for authors to follow.
We’re not trying to convince you that we’re better readers or better Christians than anyone else.
We’re simply two friends who love Jesus, love books, and want to celebrate stories that reflect the things we value.
And if we can help you discover your next favorite romance along the way?
Well, that’s a pretty wonderful bonus.
Happy reading!
Read Next:
Find Your Next Five-Star Read
What Is Clean Romance?