Five Star Reads

Each episode, Sarah and Tiffany dish about a five-star romance. These are all books that Sarah and/or Tiffany have read and loved. Enjoy this curated list that we will try to keep updated.

 

Episode 1: Why We Skip the Spice

The book cover of a book called The Perfect Rom-Com

The Perfect Rom-Com

by Melissa Ferguson

Sarah says, “The audio was so good, I immediately bought the paperback on Amazon and have been carrying it around with a highlighter. It might actually be the perfect rom-com.”

Aspiring author Bryony Page attends her first writers conference bursting with optimism and ready to sell her manuscript with long-shot dreams of raising awareness for her grandmother’s financially struggling organization where she teaches ESL full-time. What she doesn’t expect is to get tangled up with Jack Sterling, a jaded literary agent who will change everything. 

Let's Pretend book cover

Let’s Pretend

by Lindsay Rochester

Tiffany says, “It’s a fun, banter-filled celebrity romance with a tour of England that makes you feel like you’re there.”

 Finding love with a world-famous movie star seems like a dream, right?

Not to Ivy Hawkins.

She’s looking for someone with staying power, not star power, no matter how handsome. She’s worked hard growing her business, and she finally feels ready to grow personally–with the right guy. One she can trust, who will fit seamlessly into her life.

Enter Alexander Henry, last year’s Sexiest Man Alive. He and Ivy literally collide in London, and he’s immediately drawn to her–especially the fact that she isn’t fawning over him like a superfan.

Episode 2: Is Clean Romance Cheesy?

Let's Pretend book cover

Just Like Home

by Courtney Walsh

Sarah says, “Courtney Walsh books always give you all the feels. They are all so good.”

Prima ballerina Charlotte Page has a life any dancer would envy, but the tragic loss of her best friend, Julianna, leaves her wanting more. Or maybe—less. In an effort to make her life about something other than accolades and applause, Charlotte leaves professional ballet to save Julianna’s small-town dance studio. This lands her directly in the path of cranky high school football coach and Julianna’s older brother, Cole Turner.

Let's Pretend book cover

A Voice in the Wind

by Francine Rivers

Sarah and Tiffany both say, “I don’t reread much, but this series is definitely one I go back to.”

While wealthy Roman citizens indulge their every whim, Jews and barbarians are bought and sold as slaves and gladiators in the bloodthirsty arena. Amid the depravity around her, a young Jewish slave girl becomes a light in the darkness. Even as she’s torn by her love for a handsome aristocrat, Hadassah clings to her faith in the living God for deliverance from the forces of a decadent empire.

Let's Pretend book cover

Memory Lane

by Becky Wade

Tiffany says, “This whole series was so good. It goes deeper than your normal rom-com and there’s an element of mystery, too.”

After surviving a trauma several years back, Remy Reed relocated to a cottage on one of Maine’s most remote islands. She’s arranged her life just the way she wants it, spending her time working on her wood sculptures and soaking in the beauty of nature. It’s quiet and solitary—until the day she spots something bobbing in the ocean.

Episode 3: The Christmas Romance Takeover

Faking Christmas

by Cindy Steel

Tiffany and Sarah both gushed about it. You might as well listen to the episode because there was too much to type. 

One little white lie.

That’s all it took. Now I’m suddenly having to fake-date my work nemesis to get me through a week at a Vermont Christmas lodge with my family.

Episode 4: Bookish Terms

The One With the Kiss Cam

by Cindy Steel

Sarah loved how much this book made her laugh and swoon. She’s really here for the laughs.

It was just one date.

My friend told me I needed more fun in my life, so I reluctantly said yes. Fun wasn’t exactly in my wheelhouse. After watching my own mother’s love life implode time and time again it’s only natural that I have a few rules to protect myself.

Actually, it’s just one rule…

Avoid relationships with men so I don’t get attached.

The Silent Heist

by Jenessa Faith

He came for the painting…

Soren Stapley is a professional thief. He is prepared for every scenario and has a plan for every situation.

But he never planned for her.

 

Episode 5: Clean vs. Sweet

Bounty Hunter 

by Kaylee Jarvis

Tiffany loved the world-building

A king desperate to save his kingdom… in search of a woman doing everything she can to never be found…

Sometimes Love Throws a Curveball

by Laura Hawkins

Recommended by guest host Rachel Parker from @ClosedDoorRomance on Instagram

Cruz came to Maple Valley to rest and recover from a mid-season injury. Pretending to date the beautiful Airbnb hostess was not in the plan.

Neither was falling in love.

Wooing Cadie McCaffrey

by Bethany Turner

Sarah says Bethany’s books are a perfect blend of Christian, grit, and lots of humor

After four years with her boyfriend, Cadie McCaffrey is thinking of ending things. Convinced Will doesn’t love her in the “forever” way she loves him, Cadie believes it’s time for her to let him go before life passes her by.

With the dubious guidance of his former pro-athlete work friends and tactics drawn from Cadie’s favorite romantic comedies, Will attempts to win her back. It’s a foolproof plan. What could possibly go wrong?